Guest Blog: Mastery and maths - how our guidance can help

Professor Jeremy Hodgen – Chair of Mathematics Education at the UCL Institute of Education – led the evidence review underpinning the recent EEF guidance report, 'Improving Mathematics at Key Stages 2 and 3. In this blog, he discusses the links between the guidance and mastery learning.

Since the EEF guidance report was published, several teachers have asked me if the guidance encourages mastery. The short answer is yes. 

The starting point for the guidance was a series of questions from teachers about the effective ways of enabling all pupils to succeed mathematically. And, of course, these questions addressed many aspects of mastery, including fluency, use of representations, and achieving deeper understanding.

Let’s look in detail at how the recommendations in the Maths guidance report relate to the National Centre for Excellence in Teaching Mathematics’ (NCETM) Five Big Ideas for mastery: coherence, representation and structure, mathematical thinking, fluency and variation.

Coherence refers to connecting new mathematical ideas to ideas that pupils have already understood. Key to this is using assessment to understand what pupils do and do not understand in order to adapt teaching and/or provide feedback for pupils. Recommendation 1 in the EEF guidance outlines evidence-based approaches for doing this. Of course, coherence is also concerned with enabling pupils to develop a rich network of mathematical ideas, which is the overarching focus of Recommendation 4.

Representation and structure emphasises how representations should be used to expose mathematical structure and develop independent understanding, which is the focus of Recommendation 2 (Use manipulatives and representations) and Recommendation 4 (Teach pupils to recognize and use mathematical structure). The evidence indicates that how manipulatives and representations are used is crucial – teachers need to have a clear mathematical rationale. It is particularly important that manipulatives are used as a temporary tool for achieving understanding rather than becoming a crutch for pupils.

Mathematical thinking is addressed throughout the recommendations, but particularly in Recommendation 4 (Teach pupils to consciously choose between mathematical strategies, and Teach pupils to recognize and use mathematical structure), Recommendation 3 (Teach pupils problem solving strategies) and Recommendation 5 (Develop pupils’ independence and motivation). It is important that teachers provide regular opportunities for pupils to develop metacognition by encouraging them to explain their thinking to themselves and others.

Fluency stresses the importance of developing quick, and efficient, recall of number and multiplication facts, and the skilled and flexible use and application of procedures. This is tackled in Recommendation 4 (Ensure that pupils develop fluent recall of facts, Teach pupils to understand procedures, and Teach pupils to consciously choose between mathematical strategies).

Continuing Professional Development

To be published in 2021

Continuing Professional Development

EEF launches updated Teaching and Learning Toolkit

EEF launches updated Teaching and Learning Toolkit

New episode of ‘Evidence into Action’ – ‘Cognitive Science in the Classroom’

New episode of ‘Evidence into Action’ – ‘Cognitive Science in the Classroom’

Support for the design and early formative evaluation of new evidence-based programmes

Support for the design and early formative evaluation of new evidence-based programmes

Development and/or adaptation of a measure of teaching quality: call for proposals

Development and/or adaptation of a measure of teaching quality: call for proposals

Development of an EEF CRM system: call for proposals

Development of an EEF CRM system: call for proposals

New: EEF publishes evaluation of arts based education programmes

New: EEF publishes evaluation of arts based education programmes

EEF blog: Planning to address scientific misconceptions

EEF blog: Planning to address scientific misconceptions

National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners: Year 1 (2020-21)  - Reflections on scaling interventions to create system change 

National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners: Year 1 (2020-21)  - Reflections on scaling interventions to create system change 

EEF comments on delivering Year 1 of the National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners (2020-21)

EEF comments on delivering Year 1 of the National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners (2020-21)

New: EEF publishes latest reports

The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) has published a new report from a study which aimed to develop a new science attainment measure, alongside an independent evaluation of EEF projects.

New: EEF publishes latest reports

Year 5 science assessment

The Year 5 Science Assessment is a measure of Year 5 scientific ability, intended for pupils at the end of Year 5.

Year 5 science assessment

NTP year 1 evaluation

How we'll assess the impact of NTP Tuition Partners.

NTP year 1 evaluation

National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners: Year 1 (2020-21) resources

National Tutoring Programme Tuition Partners: Year 1 (2020-21) resources

EEF publishes new findings from reach and engagement evaluation

EEF publishes new findings from reach and engagement evaluation

EEF commissioned evaluations of Read Write Inc. Phonics and Fresh Start

EEF commissioned evaluations of Read Write Inc. Phonics and Fresh Start

EEF Blog: Implementing cognitive science strategies in the classroom

EEF Blog: Implementing cognitive science strategies in the classroom

EEF blog: Accelerated reader – what does the research tell us?

EEF blog: Accelerated reader – what does the research tell us?

EEF publishes two new evaluation reports

EEF publishes two new evaluation reports

Guest Blog: Retrieval practice - A common good or just commonplace?

Guest Blog: Retrieval practice - A common good or just commonplace?

New episode of ‘Evidence into Action’ – ‘Teacher Feedback to Improve Pupil Learning’

New episode of ‘Evidence into Action’ – ‘Teacher Feedback to Improve Pupil Learning’

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Focus on feedback

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Focus on feedback

New: What do we really know about cognitive science in the classroom? EEF publishes new review of the evidence

New: What do we really know about cognitive science in the classroom? EEF publishes new review of the evidence

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Applying Rosenshine’s principles to remote learning

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Applying Rosenshine’s principles to remote learning

EEF Blog: New case studies - Making effective use of diagnostic assessment

EEF Blog: New case studies - Making effective use of diagnostic assessment

EEF Blog: ECF– Exploring the Evidence: Prior knowledge and Pupil Misconceptions

EEF Blog: ECF– Exploring the Evidence: Prior knowledge and Pupil Misconceptions

EEF Blog: Three keys to unlocking positive learning behaviours

Kirsten Mould explains how schools might tackle the implementation challenge of building effective learning behaviours.

EEF Blog: Three keys to unlocking positive learning behaviours

EEF Blog: ECF – Exploring the Evidence: ‘Adaptive Teaching’ and Effective Diagnostic Assessment

EEF Blog: ECF – Exploring the Evidence: ‘Adaptive Teaching’ and Effective Diagnostic Assessment

EEF publishes findings from ‘Big Lockdown-Learning Parent Survey’

EEF publishes findings from ‘Big Lockdown-Learning Parent Survey’

New EEF podcast: Developing Oral Language

New EEF podcast: Developing Oral Language

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Guiding problem solving

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Guiding problem solving

EEF Blog: Phonics - mastering the basics of reading

EEF Blog: Phonics - mastering the basics of reading

EEF Blog: Assess, adjust, adapt – what does adaptive teaching mean to you?

EEF Blog: Assess, adjust, adapt – what does adaptive teaching mean to you?

EEF publishes new research on the impact of the pandemic on Key Stage 1 pupils’ attainment

EEF publishes new research on the impact of the pandemic on Key Stage 1 pupils’ attainment

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Delivering feedback after exam practice

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Delivering feedback after exam practice

EEF Blog: Teaching reading - Embedding comprehension strategies

EEF Blog: Teaching reading - Embedding comprehension strategies

EEF publishes findings from systematic review of attainment measures

EEF publishes findings from systematic review of attainment measures

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Making use of manipulatives

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Making use of manipulatives

How to use the Attainment Measures Database

How to use the Attainment Measures Database

Young Children’s Achievement Test – Second Edition

Young Children’s Achievement Test – Second Edition

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Secondary Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Secondary Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Early Years Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Early Years Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehenion: Primary

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehenion: Primary

Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests – Third Edition

Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests – Third Edition

Writing Assessment Tasks

Writing Assessment Tasks

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fifth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fifth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fourth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fourth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Expanded

Wide Range Achievement Test – Expanded

Word Recognition and Phonic Skills Test

Word Recognition and Phonic Skills Test

The WORD Test 3 – Elementary

The WORD Test 3 – Elementary

The WORD Test 2 – Adolescent

The WORD Test 2 – Adolescent

Woodcock-Muñoz Language Survey

Woodcock-Muñoz Language Survey

Word Identification and Spelling Test

Word Identification and Spelling Test

Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Fourth UK Edition

Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Fourth UK Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Third Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Third Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition for Teachers

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition for Teachers

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition

White Rose Maths

White Rose Maths

Collins Maths Progress Tests for White Rose (Year 1–6/P2–7)

Collins Maths Progress Tests for White Rose (Year 1–6/P2–7)

Writing Assessment Measure

Writing Assessment Measure

Test of Written Spelling – Fifth Edition

Test of Written Spelling – Fifth Edition

Tutors’ Guild Year Six Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Year Six Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Year Six English Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Year Six English Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

The Trouble with Maths

The Trouble with Maths

More Trouble with Maths

More Trouble with Maths

Test of Written Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Written Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Silent Word Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Silent Word Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Silent Reading Efficiency and Comprehension

Test of Silent Reading Efficiency and Comprehension

Test of Silent Contextual Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Silent Contextual Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Reading Comprehension – Fourth Edition

Test of Reading Comprehension – Fourth Edition

Test of Phonological Awareness – Second Edition: Plus

Test of Phonological Awareness – Second Edition: Plus

Test of Mathematical Abilities – Third Edition

Test of Mathematical Abilities – Third Edition

Test of Orthographic Competence

Test of Orthographic Competence

Test of Adolescent and Adult Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Adolescent and Adult Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Irregular Word Reading Efficiency

Test of Irregular Word Reading Efficiency

The Shanghai Maths Project – Practice Books For the English National Curriculum (Years 7–10)

The Shanghai Maths Project – Practice Books For the English National Curriculum (Years 7–10)

Test of Early Written Language – Third Edition

Test of Early Written Language – Third Edition

Test of Early Reading Ability – Fourth Edition

Test of Early Reading Ability – Fourth Edition

Test of Early Mathematics Ability – Third Edition

Test of Early Mathematics Ability – Third Edition

Single Word Spelling Test

Single Word Spelling Test

Single Word Reading Test

Single Word Reading Test

Spot the Word – Second Edition

Spot the Word – Second Edition

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition for Early Childhood

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition for Early Childhood

Social Skills Improvement System Rating Scales

Social Skills Improvement System Rating Scales

Social Skills Improvement System Performance Screening Guide

Social Skills Improvement System Performance Screening Guide

Social Skills Improvement System Classwide Intervention Program

Social Skills Improvement System Classwide Intervention Program

Snap Science – Years 1–6

Snap Science – Years 1–6

Sigma Science Assessment

Sigma Science Assessment

Shaywitz Dyslexia Screen

Shaywitz Dyslexia Screen

Symbol Digit Modalities Test

Symbol Digit Modalities Test

Scottish Heinemann Maths

Scottish Heinemann Maths

Science Knowledge Questionnaire Year 4 (Pre-test) and Year 5 (Post-test)

Science Knowledge Questionnaire Year 4 (Pre-test) and Year 5 (Post-test)

Science Assessment Series 1 and 2 – Tailored Extracts

Science Assessment Series 1 and 2 – Tailored Extracts

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Third Edition

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Third Edition

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Second Edition

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Second Edition

The idea of variation is central to mastery and emphasises the importance of presenting mathematical ideas to pupils in different ways, using a range of examples and non-examples of concepts, as well as deliberately choosing tasks to avoid ‘mechanical repetition’. Variation is a key feature of several recommendations, notably Recommendation 3 (Teach pupils strategies for solving problems), and Recommendation 6 (Use tasks and resources to challenge and support pupils’ mathematics).

The Guidance also addresses ways of developing mastery for pupils who are struggling with mathematics in Recommendation 7 (Use structured interventions to provide additional support). It is important to consider how interventions support classroom learning, and to ensure that pupils do not miss things that they enjoy or mathematics that that they need to learn.

If you are already working on mastery, how will the guidance help? The guidance highlights teaching approaches that are supported by the strongest international evidence and which are most likely to impact positively on children’s mathematical attainment. If you’re working on mastery, don’t stop! But do look to the guidance to dig deeper into the evidence on the “best bets” for developing pupils’ mathematics. And do let us know what you think and what additional material you would find useful.